Before you raise the ad budget, find out where the leads go
When sales are slow, the first instinct is to spend more on ads. Sometimes that's right. More often the trouble is what happens to the leads you already paid for, and extra budget pours more into the same leak.
The report says conversions. Your CRM says nothing.
Agency reports count "conversions". Ask what one is. Usually it's a call, a click or a form, counted by the ad platform. That isn't a lead your team spoke to, and it's a long way from a sale.
At one multi-location retailer, the CRM showed more than 2,600 ad conversions and not one lead or sale recorded against a campaign. The ads weren't necessarily failing. Nobody could tell either way.
Your close rate might be a record-keeping problem
The same retailer's CRM held about six in ten of the hot tubs and swim spas they had actually sold. The rest were sold and delivered but never marked as won. So every number built on it was wrong: close rate, cost per sale, which campaign works.
Once we matched the sales log to the CRM, the real cost per sale from paid ads came out about a fifth lower than the reports had shown. The marketing was doing better than anyone thought. The records and the follow-up were where the trouble was.
Where the money leaks
- Search terms drift. In that account, about three quarters of the swim spa search budget went to searches that never mentioned a swim spa.
- One product eats the budget. A third of the spend was producing 5% of the conversions, while the best campaign kept running out of budget.
- Nothing is spent on existing customers. Parts, chemicals and service are a large share of income at most retailers, and usually have no marketing behind them.
- Leads wait. An evening web lead that gets its first reply the next morning has already filled in someone else's form. I wrote about that here.
The order to fix it in
- Make the CRM match reality. Reconcile last quarter's sales against it.
- Tie every sale back to its source. You want sales by campaign, not clicks by campaign.
- Fix the follow-up. Every lead gets a fast first reply and more than two attempts.
- Move money from what doesn't sell to what does.
- Then decide whether the budget should go up.
Often the answer at step five is yes. The difference is that you're now raising it on campaigns you know produce sales.
Three things to ask this week
- Ask your agency what counts as a conversion in their report.
- Ask how many of last month's sales are marked as won in your CRM.
- Ask for the search terms report on your most expensive campaign.