MOONSHOTOPS Back to field notes

Your leads aren't bad. They're waiting.

"The leads from the website are junk." I hear it in almost every first conversation. Then we look at what happened to those leads.

What we usually find

At one five-store retailer, we took a sample of 22 web leads and timed the response. None of them heard from a person within five minutes. The ones that came in during the evening waited until the next morning. By then, a buyer comparing dealers that night has usually heard back from someone else.

At another retailer, 99 of 101 open hot tub leads were still marked "new lead", most with no activity logged at all.

Those leads weren't bad. Nobody had talked to them yet.

Why it happens

  • Follow-up lives in the rep's head. On a busy Saturday, the walk-in in front of them wins every time.
  • It stops after one or two tries. One call, one email, then the lead is written off as not serious.
  • Nobody can see it. Reps text from their own phones, so the business has no record of who was contacted or what was said.

None of this is a people problem. Your reps are doing what the day lets them do.

The fix has three layers

  1. The instant reply. Every new lead gets a text and an email within seconds, day or night. It buys you until morning.
  2. The chase. For two weeks, the rep is prompted to text, email and call on a set rhythm. It stops the moment the customer replies.
  3. The nurture. Anyone who hasn't bought gets something useful about the product they asked about, for up to a year. When they click or reply, the lead goes straight back to the rep that day.

The best version of this copies what your strongest rep already does and gives it to everyone.

What changed

At that five-store retailer, the share of new leads they actually reached more than doubled within weeks of switching the new system on. They didn't buy new software to do it.

Before you spend more on ads

  • Fill in your own website form at 9 pm and see when you hear back.
  • Count the open leads with no next step scheduled.
  • Ask how many times a lead is contacted before it's dropped.

More leads into a follow-up process that leaks only gets you a bigger leak.

Want to know where your business stands?

Thirty minutes with Mike. He'll tell you what he'd fix first.

Book a call with MikeOr score your business