Half your calls are going to voicemail. It isn't a staffing problem.
Ask most owners how many calls they miss and the answer is "a few". When we pull the data, it's rarely a few.
At one seven-store retailer we assessed this fall, the customer care team answered 55% of the calls that came in during business hours. In the first half hour of the day, they answered none of them. Everyone there knew calls were being missed. Nobody had seen it laid out by the hour.
It looks like a staffing problem. It usually isn't.
That retailer had good people and a phone plan with more minutes than they could ever use. What they didn't have was a system that gave a caller more than one chance.
Here's how the phones worked, and how they work in most stores I walk into:
- Every phone rings at once. Whoever is free picks up. If nobody is free, nobody does.
- There's no line to wait in. A caller gets a person or a voicemail box, with nothing in between.
- Nobody owns the voicemail. Messages get checked when someone remembers.
- Nothing is measured. No answer rate, no wait time, no record of who called back.
Adding a person to that setup helps a little. Then the busy hour comes and you're back where you started.
What a missed call actually is
On the service line, it's a customer with a problem who now has two problems. They call back less patient, or they call someone else. On the showroom line, it's a buyer partway through a five-figure decision who just learned how you'll treat them after the sale.
Fix it in this order
- Measure first. Pull one month of inbound calls and look at the answer rate by hour. The worst hours are almost always opening and closing.
- Add a queue and a callback. Let callers hold their place or ask for a call back. This one change does most of the work.
- Let customers text the same number. A lot of "calls" are a question that fits in one line.
- Then bring in AI. After hours and overflow are where it earns its keep, once the basics run properly.
I call this automation before AI. Queues and callbacks take days to set up. An AI agent that can answer a hot tub customer well takes months. Start with the thing that works next week.
Three things to check this week
- Call your own store at 8:35 on a weekday morning. See what happens.
- Ask who is responsible for returning voicemails, and by when.
- Ask your phone provider for last month's inbound calls by hour, answered and unanswered.
If the answers surprise you, you're in good company. Most owners are surprised.